| Album title | Year | Album Type | Owned |
| Visions | 1999 | EP | No |
| Fractures in the Facade of Your Porcelain Beauty | 2001 | EP | No |
| Suicide Notes and Butterfly Kisses | 2002 | Full-length | No |
| The Curse | 2004 | Full-length | No |
| A Death-Grip on Yesterday | 2006 | Full-length | No |
| Lead Sails Paper Anchor | 2007 | Full-length | Yes (MP3) |
| The Best Of... Atreyu | 2007 | Best Of/Compilation | Yes (MP3) |
| Congregation of the Damned | 2009 | Full-length | No |
| Covers of the Damned | 2010 | EP | No |
| Long Live | 2015 | Full-length | Yes (MP3) |