| Album title |
Year |
Album Type |
Owned |
| Dork | 1993 | EP | No |
| Behind the Times | 1993 | EP | No |
| Eddie Picnic's All Wet | 1994 | EP | No |
| Fly in the Ointment | 1995 | EP | No |
| AFI/Heckle Split | 1995 | Split Album | No |
| Bombing the Bay | 1995 | Split Album | No |
| He Who Laughs Last... | 1995 | Single | No |
| Answer That & Stay Fashionable | 1995 | Full-length | Yes (MP3) |
| Very Proud of Ya | 1996 | Full-length | Yes (MP3) |
| Shut Your Mouth & Open Your Eyes | 1997 | Full-length | Yes (MP3) |
| Third Season | 1997 | Single | No |
| Fire Inside EP | 1998 | EP | Yes (MP3) |
| Black Sails in the Sunset | 1999 | Full-length | Yes (MP3) |
| Black Sails EP | 1999 | EP | No |
| Alternative Press EP | 1999 | EP | No |
| All Hallows EP | 1999 | EP | Yes (MP3) |
| The Prayer Position | 1999 | Single | No |
| Totalimmortal | 1999 | Single | No |
| The Art of Drowning | 2000 | Full-length | Yes (MP3) |
| The Days of the Phoenix | 2001 | Single | No |
| Wester | 2001 | Single | No |
| 6 to 8 | 2001 | Single | No |
| 336 | 2002 | EP | No |
| Sing the Sorrow | 2003 | Full-length | Yes (CD) |
| Girl's Not Grey | 2003 | Single | No |
| The Leaving Song, Pt. II | 2003 | Single | No |
| Silver and Cold | 2003 | Single | No |
| AFI | 2004 | Best Of/Compilation | No |
| Head Like a Hole | 2004 | Single | No |
| Decemberunderground | 2006 | Full-length | No |
| Miss Murder | 2006 | Single | No |
| Love Like Winter | 2006 | Single | No |
| I Heard a Voice | 2007 | Live Album | No |
| The Missing Frame | 2007 | Single | No |
| Carcinogen Crush | 2007 | Single | No |
| Crash Love | 2009 | Full-length | No |
| Burials | 2013 | Full-length | No |